According to the Brooklyn Paper, things have gotten realy REALLY NASTY on the Brooklynian, a Park Slope community blog and message board. Discussions of the new Seventh Avenue eatery, Elementi, hit new lows (and that’s pretty low) when blog-posters began trashing the restaurant even before it opened. They were just pissed that Snooky’s went out of business and decided to take it out on the people who were opening Elementi.
It’s totally legitimate to be angry when a beloved local institution goes out of business. It’s even legitimate for people to share their pain and loss on the Internet
But is it right to condemn the incoming restaurant even before it opens? Did people on the Brooklyniam message board go beyond the beyond?
Probably. But that’s the nature of message boards.
Gersh Kuntzman, editor of the Brooklyn Paper, looked into the situation and even had dinner at the restaurant, which he enjoyed immensely. But that wasn’t the point. He just wondered if it was fair to take out the closing of Snooky’s on the new owners of Elementi.
I for one avoid the Brooklynian and think of it as a very toxic blog. Snarky and mean spirited, the Brooklynian is not where I want to spend my reading time. But hey, that’s just me.
Full disclosure: People on the Brooklynian love to trash Smartmom. Thick skin. Thick skin. I try not to take this kind of stuff too seriously. But this kind of thing can really ruin a restuarant.
Here’s an excerpt from Gersh’s article.
I asked one of the moderators of the Brooklynian message board
whether it was considered fine by Web standards to slam an eatery
before anyone has actually eaten there, but he wouldn’t really answer.
“That’s kind of like asking the Internet what it thinks about the stuff
that gets posted on it,” he said.That wasn’t enough for me, so I contacted Caseopele myself. She seemed proud of her handiwork.
“I
have a bit of a problem with people who push older businesses out only
to open another cookie-cutter business in its place,” she wrote via
e-mail.I reminded her that no one “pushed” Snooky’s out — that
it merely closed for lack of business — but she responded that the
Rutledges “turned a perfectly good restaurant into what they thought
Park Slope needed. They think they know what the neighborhood wants but
they never ask.”But that that’s what business people do: look
around, make their judgment and let the market — not anonymous yahoos
on Yahoo! — make its ruling (just as the market did to Snooky’s).And
then I did something that Caseopele never did: I ate at Elementi. Full
disclosure? It was a kick-ass meal, from the pappardelle with oxtail to
the skirt steak.So as far as I’m concerned, the issue is
settled. Now, can we all get back to using Web forums for important
discussions, like the gender of a toddler’s winter hat?




